|
A Sample of Considerations to Inform a
Holistic Design Approach towards
Healthier Mental Environments in Schools |
Summary
Teachers and School staff, especially in State Schools, struggle to deliver the standard of education they aim for and consequently, cases of stress related illness have been increasing.
Resources for renovations and school improvements are not plentiful, but where they are available, taking a holistic design approach can work to help alleviate levels of stress.
Assessing working and teaching environments on a project by project basis with a holistic range of physical, operational and psychological considerations, informs a design strategy that can be implemented to improve working conditions and wellness in the work place.
As a result, schools benefit as levels of stress-related absences fall, allowing staff and teachers to deliver the level of education they strive for, and make the positive difference in the lives of the young people they came in to the profession to inspire.
Kids only go through school once, and school days are meant to be amongst our best days. We owe it to them to make this time a positive and uplifting experience.
Causes of Teacher's Sickness in Uk State Schools
A combination of factors contributes to the high levels of sickness absence among teachers in UK state schools. Some of the primary causes include:
1. Workload and Stress:
One of the most significant factors is the high workload, which includes planning lessons, marking, and administrative tasks. Many teachers report working well beyond contracted hours, which leads to stress and burnout. The pressure to meet targets, such as exam results and Ofsted inspections, also adds to this stress.
2. Mental Health Issues:
The stress and pressure of the job can lead to mental health problems, including anxiety and depression. Teachers often face challenging classroom environments, lack of support, and increasing demands from parents and school leadership, which exacerbate these issues.
3. Physical Health:
Teaching can be physically demanding. Long hours on their feet, exposure to illnesses in schools (such as colds and flu), and insufficient breaks can lead to physical health problems. Moreover, stress and burnout can also manifest in physical symptoms, leading to more frequent sickness absences.
4. Lack of Resources and Support:
Many teachers feel that they lack adequate resources, including teaching materials, support staff, and time, to do their jobs effectively. This can increase stress levels and lead to feelings of frustration and helplessness, contributing to sickness.
5. Pupil Behaviour:
Managing pupil behaviour is another significant challenge. Disruptive behaviour in the classroom can lead to stress and anxiety, particularly when teachers feel unsupported by school leadership in dealing with these issues.
6. Pay and Conditions:
Some teachers feel that their pay does not reflect the amount of work and stress involved in the job. Combined with worsening working conditions in some schools, this can lead to dissatisfaction and a higher likelihood of taking time off.
7. COVID-19 Pandemic:
The pandemic has exacerbated existing issues, with teachers facing additional stress from the shift to online teaching, concerns about health and safety in schools, and the challenge of helping pupils catch up after periods of disruption.
Addressing these issues requires systemic changes, including reducing workload, improving mental health support, ensuring adequate resources, and fostering a supportive school environment. Without such changes, high levels of sickness absence among teachers are likely to continue.
How Architecture and Interior Design Can Help Schools and the Teaching Environment Work More Effectively
Architecture and interior design can play a significant role in enhancing the effectiveness of schools and improving the workplace for teachers. Thoughtful design can create environments that reduce stress, enhance well-being, and foster collaboration among staff. Here are some strategies and contributions that architecture and interior design can offer:
1. Optimising Layout and Space Planning
Flexible Workspaces:
Designing spaces that can be easily reconfigured allows teachers to adapt their environment to different teaching styles or activities. For instance, movable walls, modular furniture, and adaptable classrooms can create spaces that support both individual work and collaborative activities.
Efficient Use of Space:
Thoughtful space planning ensures that areas are used effectively, reducing clutter and creating a more organised environment. This can include well-planned storage spaces, designated areas for different activities, and efficient circulation paths.
 |
Ventilating the classroom:
1 High level ventilation grilles
2 Cross ventilation with grilles or openable windows on both sides of the classroom
3 Heat from radiators tempers air as it comes in |
2. Improving Natural Light and Ventilation
Natural Light:
Access to natural light is crucial for well-being and productivity. Classrooms, offices, and common areas designed with large windows or skylights can reduce reliance on artificial lighting, improve mood, and decrease eye strain.
Ventilation:
Proper ventilation is essential for maintaining air quality and comfort. Designing spaces with good airflow, using windows that open, or incorporating advanced HVAC systems can help reduce the spread of illnesses and improve overall comfort.
3. Incorporating Biophilic Design
Natural Elements:
Incorporating natural elements such as plants, wood textures, and views of nature into the school environment can reduce stress and enhance well-being. Biophilic design principles suggest that exposure to nature has a calming effect and can improve focus and productivity.
Outdoor Learning Spaces:
Designing outdoor spaces that can be used for teaching or relaxation provides an alternative environment that can reduce stress and encourage creativity. Gardens, courtyards, and green spaces can be used for lessons, breaks, or staff meetings.
4. Creating Collaborative and Social Spaces
Staff Rooms and Lounges:
Designing comfortable, welcoming staff rooms where teachers can relax, socialise, and collaborate is crucial. These spaces should be equipped with comfortable seating, adequate lighting, and amenities like kitchens or coffee stations to encourage social interaction and provide a mental break.
Open and Shared Spaces:
Designing open spaces that encourage informal meetings and collaboration among teachers can foster a sense of community and support. These spaces can include seating areas, shared desks, or communal tables where teachers can easily interact.
 |
Considering acoustic treatment:
1 Acoustic ceiling panels
2 High level acoustic wall panels
3 Cork and felt lined display boards
4 Sound proofing from outside activities |
5. Acoustic Design for Noise Control
Soundproofing:
Reducing noise levels in classrooms and staff areas is vital for concentration and stress reduction. Acoustic panels, carpeting, and sound-absorbing materials can be used to minimize noise pollution.
Quiet Zones:
Creating designated quiet areas where teachers can work undisturbed is important for tasks requiring focus, such as lesson planning or grading. These zones can be separate from busy areas to ensure a peaceful environment.
6. Ergonomic and Comfortable Furniture
Ergonomics:
Providing ergonomic furniture for teachers, such as adjustable chairs, desks at appropriate heights, and comfortable seating options, can prevent physical strain and promote health. Teachers often spend long hours at their desks, so ensuring comfort is crucial.
Teacher Workstations:
Designing personal workspaces that are well-organised and equipped with necessary tools can increase efficiency. These stations should allow teachers to move freely, have sufficient storage, and be conducive to both administrative tasks and creative planning.
|
Make natural light work for you:
1 External canopy or louvres blocks high energy sunlight but can bounce light in to the classroom
2 Light coloured ceilings reflect light in the room
3 Low angle, low energy sunlight can offer warmth and atmosphere
4 Consider opportunities for north light or roof lights
5 Solar control and blackout blinds control natural light levels for displays etc. |
7. Colour and Lighting Psychology
Colour Schemes:
The use of colour can significantly affect mood and productivity. Calm and neutral tones in classrooms and staff areas can reduce stress, while strategic use of vibrant colours can energise and inspire creativity.
 |
Electric lighting strategy:
1 Main lights offer even distribution of light
2 Some illumination of the ceiling adds a sense of space
3 Lighting to assist specific activities or displays |
Lighting Design:
Beyond natural light, the design of artificial lighting is important. Warm, adjustable lighting can create a more relaxing atmosphere in staff areas, while bright, focused lighting can enhance concentration in classrooms.
 |
| An example of colours selected to bring life and energy in to a room |
8. Health and Wellness Features
Rest and Relaxation Areas:
Incorporating areas specifically designed for relaxation, such as nap rooms, meditation spaces, or wellness rooms, can provide teachers with a space to recharge during the day.
Fitness and Wellness Facilities:
On-site fitness facilities or outdoor exercise areas can encourage physical activity, which is beneficial for both physical and mental health.
9. Sustainability and Environmental Considerations
Sustainable Materials:
Using sustainable, non-toxic materials in the construction and furnishing of schools can improve indoor air quality and reduce environmental impact. This contributes to a healthier environment for both students and staff.
Energy Efficiency:
Designing energy-efficient buildings with considerations for insulation, lighting, and heating can reduce operational costs and create a more comfortable environment. Schools can also incorporate renewable energy sources, like solar panels, to enhance sustainability.
10. Safety and Accessibility
Inclusive Design:
Ensuring that the school environment is accessible to all staff and students, regardless of physical ability, is crucial. This includes designing ramps, accessible restrooms, and ensuring all areas are reachable and usable by everyone.
Safety Features:
Incorporating safety features such as secure entry points, clear signage, and well-lit pathways contributes to a sense of security and reduces anxiety among staff and students.
By incorporating these architectural and interior design strategies, schools can create environments that support teacher well-being, enhance productivity, and foster a positive and collaborative work culture. This holistic approach to design can significantly contribute to reducing stress, preventing burnout, and ultimately improving the effectiveness of teaching and learning.
Percentage of Teachers Reporting Stress and Sickness in UK State Schools
The exact percentage of teaching staff who go on sick leave due to stress in UK state schools can vary based on the specific source and time frame. However, some general trends and figures can be provided based on available data and research.
Stress-Related Sickness in UK State Schools
It is estimated that around 50-60% of sick leave in UK state schools is stress-related, according to various surveys and studies conducted among teachers. This reflects the high levels of stress due to factors such as heavy workloads, challenging pupil behaviour, and pressure from standardised testing and inspections (such as Ofsted).
According to the National Education Union (NEU), stress and mental health issues are among the top reasons for teacher sickness absence in state schools. The exact percentage of teachers taking sick leave due to stress can vary, but it is often cited as a significant factor in the overall sickness absence rates.
 |
Lighting control in the art studio at Furzedown Primary School, London SW17.
Solar control blinds block glare and offer views out.
North lights bring diffused light in to the studio space.
Blackout blinds control light levels for AV presentations.
Perimeter spot lights assist the general lighting strategy. |
The Estimated Percentage Reduction in Work Related Sickness
if Schools Incorporate the Measures Above to Improve Work Spaces
Estimating the precise percentage reduction in work-related sickness due to improvements in workspaces, such as those suggested here involves a degree of speculation, as the impact of such measures can vary significantly based on implementation quality, the specific context of the school, and individual differences among staff. However, based on research and evidence from similar interventions in other sectors, some general estimates can be made.
General Impact of Workplace Improvements:
Research from various fields, including education, healthcare, and corporate environments, shows that improving workspaces can lead to substantial reductions in stress-related sickness and overall absenteeism. Key factors include:
1. Reduced Stress and Burnout:
Improvements in natural lighting, ventilation, ergonomic furniture, and noise control can significantly reduce stress levels, which are a major contributor to work-related sickness. Studies suggest that such changes can reduce stress-related absenteeism by anywhere from 10% to 30%.
2. Enhanced Well-being and Job Satisfaction:
Creating comfortable, collaborative, and supportive work environments (e.g., through biophilic design, social spaces, and quiet zones) can improve teachers' overall well-being and job satisfaction. This can lead to reductions in burnout and associated sickness absences by an estimated 15% to 25%.
3. Improved Mental Health Support:
Providing spaces that support mental health, such as wellness rooms and outdoor relaxation areas, can help mitigate anxiety and depression, which are common causes of long-term sickness. The reduction in mental health-related absences might be in the range of 10% to 20%.
Estimated Overall Reduction
Taking into account these factors, a well-implemented, holistic approach to improving school workspaces could potentially reduce work-related sickness by 20% to 40% overall. This estimate assumes that the changes are thoughtfully integrated and address both physical and psychological aspects of the work environment.
Example Calculation
If a school currently has a work-related sickness absence rate of, say, 10% of staff annually, incorporating these measures could reduce this rate to between 6% and 8%. In a school with 100 staff members, this might mean reducing the number of staff on long-term sickness leave from 10 to between 6 and 8, depending on the effectiveness of the interventions.
Conclusion
While these estimates provide a general idea, the actual impact would depend on various factors, including the specific challenges faced by the school, the baseline level of work-related sickness, and how effectively the proposed improvements are implemented. Schools that invest in creating supportive, well-designed environments are likely to see significant reductions in stress-related sickness, contributing to better teacher retention, morale, and overall school performance.
